News
PhiladelphiaEagles.com » News » Story
Change Font Size - SmallerChange Font Size - Larger Corrections Button Podcast Send To A Friend Print This Page RSS Feed
 
 


 
Fan-Demonium: Sudden Impact
 
April 30, 2008 | Last Updated: 4/30/08 11:25 AM ET | Comments (10)
By: TOMMY LAWLOR


alt

I'm excited about the Eagles draft class. I know some fans are upset with Andy Reid and Tom Heckert for trading out of the first round. They feel the team should have taken some "impact" player." I said for most of the spring that the team would move up or back. Either way, I figured they would not stay with the 19th pick. The value was awkward for the team at that spot.

Reid said the Eagles tried to move up, but weren't able to pull off a deal. Who they targeted isn't all that important. The deals didn't come to fruition so Reid and Heckert did the wise thing in moving back. The extra first-round pick will make next year's draft a lot of fun. The Eagles will have a chance to be very aggressive or add some key players.

Sudden Impact

I really like the group of players the Eagles added. One of the things I like most is that the players who were drafted offer some immediate help. Huh? Didn't they trade back? How could those guys add impact? The players we took fit into the lineup as role players.

Trevor Laws has a chance to play right away. I fully expect him to challenge for the No. 3 defensive tackle spot this summer. DeSean Jackson should be the primary punt returner from the minute he hits the practice field. Bryan Smith can be a situational rusher. Quintin Demps could play his way to being the No. 3 safety early on. He also could be the primary kickoff returner.

The draft picks have the skill set and experience to handle the roles I mentioned. Laws is a high-motor defensive tackle. He will go 100 mph on every snap. That is perfect for a backup lineman. Jackson returned six punts for a touchdown at Cal. He was the most dynamic returner in the whole draft. Smith had 31 career sacks. He is a pure pass rusher. Put him at end and tell him to go get the quarterback. Demps has experience at corner and safety. He has experience returning kickoffs and punts. Expect immediate impact from this draft class.

If Anything, The Eagles Are Faster

Tommy Lawlor, goeagles99 on the Discussion Boards, is an amateur football scout and devoted Eagles fan. He's followed the team for almost 20 years. Tommy has been trained by an NFL scout in the art of scouting and player evaluation and runs www.scoutsnotebook.com.
The Eagles got faster this weekend. DeSean Jackson ran the fastest time of the wide receivers at the Combine. Not only is he fast, but click here and watch highlights of him running routes. He is smooth and under control. That kind of speed translates to the field. He's not just a track guy or a player running hard. Demps ran the fastest time of the free safeties at the Combine. Bryan Smith ran a 4.66 in the 40 at his Pro Day, which makes him one of the fastest defensive ends to be picked. Offensive lineman Mike Gibson had a very good showing at the Combine. Andy Studebaker had a great workout at his Pro Day. Last year the team added size and strength. This year the focus was on getting faster.

Special Teams Will Be Better

One of the keys to this draft class was getting guys who could contribute on special teams. The Eagles did a great job of that. Jackson and Demps are gifted return men with seven career touchdowns between them. They bring speed and excitement to the return game. The offense had trouble scoring points last year. One of the key problems was always having to go a long way. The Eagles were near the bottom of the league in average starting field position. That should not be the case with the rookie returners now on hand.

Jackson is incredibly elusive. He can make multiple guys miss. He offers not only the ability to break 15-20 yard returns, but someone who can produce game-changing plays. Don't expect him to be like Devin Hester, but there is a good chance that punt returns will be exciting on a regular basis for the first time since 2003 when Brian Westbrook was the full-time punt returner. When he does get out in the open, no one is going to catch him with the kind of speed he has.

Trevor Laws blocked three kicks this year and six for his career. He also is the kind of guy who will be more than happy to go out and cover kicks or block on the return units. Bryan Smith has the size and speed to be a factor on the coverage units. Mike McGlynn was the long snapper at Pitt for three years. He can be a backup to Jon Dorenbos or possibly challenge for his job. Studebaker could be very good at covering kicks. He's big and runs well. Joe Mays could be outstanding on special teams. He might remind you of former players Jason Short, Keith Adams or Tank Daniels. Mays is a powerful hitter and very aggressive player. I can easily see him blowing up the wedge on kickoffs.

Another Defensive Tackle?

Some fans are uncomfortable with the notion that the team's first draft choice projects to being a backup for the foreseeable future. I understand where those fans are coming from, but don't agree with them.

Probably the two best defensive units Jim Johnson has had in Philly featured three good defensive tackles. The 2001 team had Corey Simon, Hollis Thomas and Paul Grasmanis. The 2004 unit had Simon, Darwin Walker and Sam Rayburn. You really need three players to rotate on the inside.

I was very happy to see the team select Trevor Laws. He has the skill set and attitude to handle being a backup. Check out this blurb from an interview Matt Alkire did with him for ScoutsNotebook.com. In response to being asked the difference between practice and games, Laws said, "There is something more live about when the running back has the ball and you have the chance to put some punishment on him."

Does that sound like the kind of guy you want coming off the bench or what? The full interview is still posted at ScoutsNotebook.com.

Our Crystal Ball Was Accurate

  • Back in December we posted an All-American team at Scouts Notebook. Trevor Laws was one of the defensive tackles. Quintin Demps was the free safety.
  • I also wrote this blurb in December about Mike McGlynn: "Let's talk about offensive linemen. Two guys I love to watch are Mike McGlynn of Pitt and Devin Clark of New Mexico. Neither guy has the feet for tackle in the NFL. They'll need to shift inside and play guard. I love watching both guys because they are physical, nasty blockers. They really get after the defender that they're blocking. Some linemen are almost passive as they block. Not these guys. They attack."
  • Among the undrafted players, receivers Shaheer McBride and Terrell Golden are perfect for the West Coast offense. I'm just not sure if they are athletic enough for the NFL. Frantz Hardy is a clone of Greg Lewis, in size and style of play. Tackle Franklin Dunbar is the best player. He has a good shot to make the practice squad if he shows he can handle NFL speed this summer at Lehigh.
Fan-Demonium: Sudden Impact
   
PhelanJo@...
05/02/08
10:25 am ET
hey brizer9 thats one position dueshbag. The patriots started zero rookies last year. How was their season. You only start rookies out of necesity. I forgot more than you know about football. How many rookie free agents even make the team. You wait and see when this guy from Cal gets his first hit in the NFL. I believe Troy Aikman was 1-15 in his rookie. I go back to SB 5 how long have you been following the game.
brizer9@...
05/01/08
11:26 pm ET
I don't have any issues with what the Poet has to say,..maybe it's you phelatio who doesn't know a lick about america's game...as the Poet astutely points out,..DT is a position that Rookies play all the time,..easiest to learn..barring injury and'/or some other unforeseen event (like Reagor coming back very strong) Laws will be a rotating starter,..perk up.
rohash@...
05/01/08
9:06 pm ET
Initially I wasn't too thrilled with this draft either but there are some players I like and I'm willing to give them a chance and have some faith in Reid and company. They've drafted fairly well in the past. We won't know until a couple years down the road, nobody will. I wouldn't bank on the Carolina's pick next year being a top ten. With a healthy Delhomme, I would say they are the favorite to win that division. Dallas probably thought they were getting a surefire top 10 from Cleveland last year.
PhelanJo@...
05/01/08
7:30 am ET
aapoet you obviously don't know crap about football. Dynasty, what crack house did you fall out of buddy. Your comparing college football to the pro's give me a break. You act like your the coach. Laurie is to cheap to have a dynasty. Half of these players will get cut. Lets put your money where your mouth how about a wager on who gets cut or playing time. You don't know crap about the NFL or the Eagles.
brizer9@...
04/30/08
9:54 pm ET
Hey Tommy,.if his time at PSU hasn't made him regress,..Golden should easily be athletic enough for NFL,..see below.....his current problem is landing on the Eagles loaded with competition. He's got Devin Thomas size!... Earned SuperPrep All-America and all-state honors as a senior. Was named first-team all-district in basketball as a junior and senior, and also lettered in track. Finished second in the state long jump competition as a junior and was third in both the long jump and triple jump at the state championships as a senior. Earned a
goeagles99
04/30/08
5:30 pm ET
Phelan...I understand where you are coming from. Here is something I wrote last year: "The one thing you really have to keep in mind is that this draft was really about the future. Kolb will ride the pine for 2-3 years. Hunt will be a role player. Abiamiri might not get on the field much this year. Bradley is my favorite pick. Why? His addition makes Dhani Jones expendable. Plus, he's got the best hair in the draft. Gaddis, Celek, and Barksdale might earn backup roles for '07, but also might be inactive a lot. Ilaoa has to learn how to play FB instead of RB. " ----------- Clearly I was not expecting much, if any, impact from the 2007 class. That group was taken at deep spots or the players were going to need time. The class of 2008 is completely different. I don't want you to think I'm talking about them as starters. I'm talking about them as backups and key role players. Rookies can handle those kinds of jobs. Expect this group to have impact starting this weekend.
goeagles99
04/30/08
5:27 pm ET
JB99...I'll always welcome a quick/fast pass rusher to the fold. How nice would it have been to have him last year vs the Bears on that final drive? I'm excited about having that extra 1st next year. I just hope we're picking in the 30's and Carolina is in the top ten.
aapoet@...
04/30/08
3:54 pm ET
I'm correcting you, Phelan, because you are wrong. It's not a rule that coaches don't play rookies or 1 st year free agents, it just often works out that way as they play the young players from the year before who have better learned the system. This situation will be different because of the players and positions. DTs can often play in their first year, and in fact Bunk would have played more in his first year if he had come to training camp. Laws will play. He gives the line what it was missing ... a solid player to relive Bunk and Patterson. DeSean Jackson will be our punt returner right away. That doesn't take much understanding of a new system. It's instincts and ability, and he has loads. (And, I predict that he can run some go routes to stretch the field to add another dimension by the bye week.) Booker already has a year under his belt. That takes care of the first day picks and acquisitions. After that, it's often projects, though I believe that Smith and Demps will both get time in the rotations. Also, like Tommy mentions, we got a lot of good special teams players. I love this draft for present and future. We might look back on this as the beginning of a dynasty ... or at least another stretch of great seasons. I had Jackson on my short list for round 1 and Laws on my short list for round 2, so to get them both and get a first rounder next year is like cheesesteaks and Tastykakes to me.
PhelanJo@...
04/30/08
2:40 pm ET
Maybe thats why they call you an amature scout. I've been following the Eagles since super bowl five. I can't remember many rookies or 1st year free agents that make an impact right away. They usually make mistakes costly ones because of nerves. How you can say these players will make an impact is beyond me. Reid screwed up again not taking a deep threat thats tall and strong. Screw next year I want to win this year. Coaches don't play rookies and first year free agents. Please correct me if I'm wrong. Just look at the rookie tackle against the Giants this year. Because of our current wide recievers how many coverage sacks will we give up this year. Try to get Ocho Cinco pay him the money to keep his mouth shut. example TO in Dallas. Give McNabb a decent reciever and tight end. Please Jeff.
JeromeBrown99
04/30/08
1:38 pm ET
goeagles99... Good call on McGlynn. And your right he could beat out Dorenbos. Save US a roster spot. === Couldn't be happier with these picks. I was a little surprised to see Smith go in 3rd. But he has incredible jump off the snap. And like I've told other people... I'd rather have him... than not have him. I don't care where WE picked him. And WE got twice as fast as a TEAM overall. I love Laws and Demps. Laws, Smith and Clemons solidify the D-line. Booker is a guy that can step in and catch 50 passes if #36 goes down 1st game. An we kept Lito. Perfect! I still can't believe we got Panthers 1st rounder in '09! Thats a 15 at least IMO. We can package those 2 1st rounders. The Panthers 15(or better) and our 32 and get Mike Oher! Thats 1 name for '09. Oher could fit right in!



 

 
 
 
 
 
11/22/09   @ Bears
11/22/09   Miller Away Game Party
11/23/09   Primetime Live
11/27/09   Eagles Friday
11/28/09   Santa SWOOP At End Zone